Feedback Rubrics for the Visual Arts

Story about

Rebecca Recco

Visual Arts Teacher at Cindy Avitia High School, California

Feedback Rubrics for the Visual Arts

Rebecca Recco teaches Visual Arts in San Jose, California. She’s been an advocate for peer feedback throughout her 18 years as an educator. Throughout the years, peer feedback has taken many forms for her including detailed worksheets, rubrics, and even post-it notes.

As an art teacher, Rebecca finds two main reasons for using peer feedback. With peer feedback, students are getting the opportunity to hear how their artwork is perceived by others. The other reason Rebecca loves peer feedback is that it gives students ownership of both the learning process and their artwork.

How does an art class use online peer feedback?

One of the biggest hurdles Rebecca had to get over to implementing Peergrade was tech related. Students art was offline but needed to get online for anonymous peer feedback. Rebecca gives students’ents permission to use their cell phones to take higher quality pictures of their art and put it in a Google Drive to share on Peergrade. The little bit of extra effort on both her and the students part enables for anonymous and effective feedback. “The initial reaction was great because giving feedback can be really awkward, so kids tend to want to only provide feedback for their friends. They were relieved to know that their feedback would be anonymous!”

“I like giving students ownership of their learning and artistic process as often as possible, and peer feedback is more valuable for that reason than teacher feedback.”

What does a Feeback Rubric look like for the Visual Arts?

“Students are reinforcing their understanding of the Elements and Principles through the authentic work of creating and assessing art”.

Rebecca ties her Feedback Rubric to the Elements of Art and Principles of Design so students reinforce their understanding of the class concepts. She also sticks to a terminology in the Feedback Rubric that is familiar to her students, “glows and grows”. Glows are areas that work well and grows are areas that can be improved. The familiarity of terminology combined with the security of anonymity has encouraged Rebecca’s students to dive deeper and provide feedback that goes beyond ‘good job’.

Most of Rebecca’s Feedback Rubric questions are text response questions allowing students to express their own thoughts and feelings towards the artwork. Below are a few examples of the questions that Rebecca uses for her art students:
 



Share this article

Other stories

Peer Learning in Executive Education at INSEAD

INSEAD works hard to maintain their reputation as “The Business School for the World”. They educate participants across campuses in Europe, Asia, and the Middle East with a world-renowned faculty from over 40 countries. They have been educating business professionals since 1957 and their dedicated focus to graduate level and executive education has earned them […]

Read story

Building Confidence in Peer Feedback

Utrecht University is one of the oldest universities in the Netherlands and has distinguished itself by producing 12 Nobel Prize laureates. These days it is home to 7 faculties with 49 bachelor programs and 147 master programs. UU educates over thirty-thousand students in both Dutch and English degree programs. Utrecht’s long history has not kept […]

Read story

Game and Web Design with Peer Feedback

In an ideal world, there would be enough class time for students to present their projects to the entire class get feedback and have the teacher hand grade each project. Unfortunately, very few teachers live in this ideal world where there is time for everything. Steve Floro teaches Game and Web Design to high school […]

Read story